Amazon Automatic vs Manual PPC Campaigns: Which Should You Use?

Introduction

One of the most common questions Amazon sellers ask is: “Should I use Automatic or Manual PPC campaigns?”

The answer isn’t simple—both campaign types serve different purposes and work best when used together strategically. Understanding when and how to use each type is crucial for Amazon PPC success.

The truth: Most successful Amazon sellers use both Automatic and Manual campaigns in a coordinated strategy. Automatic campaigns discover keywords, while Manual campaigns scale profitable ones.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down Automatic vs Manual campaigns, show you when to use each, and teach you how to create a winning campaign strategy that maximizes ROI.

What Are Amazon Automatic Campaigns?

Definition:

Amazon Automatic campaigns let Amazon’s algorithm automatically target your ads based on your product listing. You don’t choose keywords—Amazon does it for you.

How Automatic Campaigns Work:

1. Amazon analyzes your listing:

• Product title
• Bullet points
• Product description
• Backend keywords
• Product category

1. Amazon matches to searches:

• Related customer searches
• Similar product searches
• Category-based matching
• Algorithm-driven targeting

1. You control:

• Daily budget
• Default bid
• Campaign name
• That’s it!

Automatic Campaign Features:

• No keyword management – Amazon handles targeting
• Broad reach – Targets many search variations
• Easy setup – Just set budget and bid
• Discovery focused – Finds keywords you’d never think of
• Low maintenance – Minimal ongoing management

What Are Amazon Manual Campaigns?

Definition:

Amazon Manual campaigns give you complete control. You choose exact keywords, set individual bids, and control match types.

How Manual Campaigns Work:

1. You choose keywords:

• Specific search terms
• Based on research
• From Automatic campaigns
• Competitor analysis

1. You set bids:

• Per keyword bids
• Bid adjustments
• Match type control
• Precise targeting

1. You control everything:

• Which keywords to target
• How much to bid
• Match type (Broad, Phrase, Exact)
• Negative keywords

Manual Campaign Features:

• Full control – Choose every keyword
• Precise targeting – Exact search terms
• Bid optimization – Per-keyword bids
• Match type control – Broad, Phrase, Exact
• Higher maintenance – Requires ongoing optimization

Automatic vs Manual: Key Differences

Control Level:

Use Cases:

Performance Characteristics:

When to Use Automatic Campaigns

Best For:

1. New Products

Why:

• No keyword data yet
• Amazon finds relevant searches
• Discovers long-tail opportunities
• Low effort, high value

Strategy:

• Start with Automatic
• Run for 1-2 weeks
• Extract search terms
• Move winners to Manual

2. Keyword Discovery

Why:

• Finds keywords you’d never think of
• Discovers search variations
• Identifies long-tail opportunities
• Reveals customer language

Strategy:

• Run Automatic continuously
• Weekly search terms review
• Harvest converting terms
• Add to Manual campaigns

3. Low Competition Niches

Why:

• Less need for precise control
• Amazon’s algorithm works well
• Lower maintenance required
• Good for testing

Strategy:

• Use Automatic as primary
• Monitor performance
• Optimize bids
• Add Manual for top keywords

4. Limited Time/Resources

Why:

• Minimal setup required
• Low maintenance
• Amazon handles optimization
• Good starting point

Strategy:

• Start with Automatic
• Learn from data
• Gradually add Manual
• Scale what works

When to Use Manual Campaigns

Best For:

1. Scaling Profitable Keywords

Why:

• Precise bid control
• Better ACoS management
• Optimize per keyword
• Maximum efficiency

Strategy:

• Move winners from Automatic
• Set optimal bids
• Use Exact Match
• Scale budget

2. High Competition Keywords

Why:

• Need precise control
• Competitive bidding required
• Strategic bid management
• Better ROI potential

Strategy:

• Manual campaigns only
• Exact Match for control
• Aggressive bidding
• Continuous optimization

3. Brand and Competitor Campaigns

Why:

• Specific keyword targeting
• Brand name protection
• Competitor targeting
• Strategic positioning

Strategy:

• Separate Manual campaigns
• Brand keywords: Lower bids
• Competitor keywords: Higher bids
• Monitor closely

4. Advanced Optimization

Why:

• Per-keyword optimization
• Match type testing
• Negative keyword control
• Maximum efficiency

Strategy:

• Full Manual setup
• Extensive optimization
• Daily monitoring
• Data-driven decisions

The Hybrid Strategy: Best of Both Worlds

Recommended Approach:

Use Both Together Strategically

Phase 1: Discovery (Weeks 1-2)

• Automatic Campaigns: Primary
• Budget: 60-70% of total
• Let Amazon find keywords
• Extract search terms weekly

• Manual Campaigns: Secondary
• Budget: 30-40% of total
• Known high-value keywords
• Brand and competitor terms

Phase 2: Optimization (Weeks 3-4)

• Automatic Campaigns: Continue
• Ongoing discovery
• Lower budget: 40-50%
• Focus on new keywords

• Manual Campaigns: Scale
• Higher budget: 50-60%
• Winners from Automatic
• Optimize bids and match types

Phase 3: Scaling (Weeks 5+)

• Automatic Campaigns: Maintenance
• 20-30% of budget
• Continuous discovery
• Harvest new opportunities

• Manual Campaigns: Primary
• 70-80% of budget
• Scaling profitable keywords
• Maximum efficiency

How to Set Up Automatic Campaigns

Step 1: Campaign Creation

1. Go to Seller Central → Advertising → Campaign Manager
2. Click “Create Campaign”
3. Choose “Sponsored Products”
4. Select “Automatic targeting”
5. Name your campaign (e.g., “Auto – Discovery”)

Step 2: Campaign Settings

Settings:

• Campaign Name: Descriptive (e.g., “Auto – [Product Name]”)
• Daily Budget: Start with 10-15% of target revenue
• Start Date: Immediate or scheduled
• End Date: None (ongoing)

Step 3: Ad Group Setup

Ad Group:

• Name: Match campaign or product-specific
• Default Bid: Start conservative (e.g., $0.50-1.00)
• Products: Select products to advertise

Step 4: Launch and Monitor

After Launch:

• Let run for 1-2 weeks
• Don’t make changes too quickly
• Collect data first
• Then optimize

How to Set Up Manual Campaigns

Step 1: Campaign Creation

1. Go to Seller Central → Advertising → Campaign Manager
2. Click “Create Campaign”
3. Choose “Sponsored Products”
4. Select “Manual targeting”
5. Name your campaign (e.g., “Manual – Brand Keywords”)

Step 2: Campaign Settings

Settings:

• Campaign Name: Descriptive by goal
• Daily Budget: Based on strategy
• Start Date: Immediate
• End Date: None

Step 3: Ad Group and Keywords

Ad Group Setup:

• Name: Match keyword theme
• Default Bid: Starting bid for keywords
• Products: Select products

Add Keywords:

• Research-based keywords
• From Automatic campaigns
• Competitor keywords
• Brand terms

Step 4: Match Types

Choose Match Types:

• Broad Match: Discovery, high volume
• Phrase Match: Balanced
• Exact Match: Precise, converting

Strategy:

• Start with Exact Match
• Add Phrase for testing
• Use Broad for discovery

Step 5: Bid Management

Set Bids:

• New keywords: Start conservative
• From Automatic: Based on performance
• Brand keywords: Lower bids
• Competitor keywords: Higher bids

Optimizing Automatic Campaigns

Optimization Strategies:

1. Bid Optimization

• High ACoS: Lower default bid
• Low ACoS: Raise default bid
• Test adjustments: Small changes
• Monitor impact: Weekly review

2. Search Terms Analysis

• Export weekly: Search Terms Report
• Identify winners: Converting terms
• Find losers: High-ACoS terms
• Harvest keywords: Move to Manual

3. Negative Keywords

• Add irrelevant terms: Prevent wasted clicks
• High-ACoS searches: Exclude non-converting
• Regular review: Weekly updates
• Save money: Reduce wasted spend

4. Budget Allocation

• Winners: Increase budget
• Losers: Decrease or pause
• Test new products: Allocate budget
• Scale what works: Focus on profitable

Optimizing Manual Campaigns

Optimization Strategies:

1. Keyword Performance Analysis

• Track per keyword: ACoS, conversions
• Pause losers: High ACoS, no sales
• Scale winners: Low ACoS, high sales
• Test new keywords: Regular additions

2. Bid Optimization

• Per-keyword bids: Individual optimization
• High performers: Raise bids 10-20%
• Low performers: Lower bids 20-30%
• Break-even: Test adjustments

3. Match Type Strategy

• Exact Match: Converting keywords
• Phrase Match: Testing new terms
• Broad Match: Discovery only
• Optimize based on performance

4. Negative Keywords

• Full control: Exclude irrelevant searches
• Regular updates: Weekly review
• Save money: Prevent wasted clicks
• Improve ACoS: Better targeting

Automatic vs Manual: Performance Comparison

Typical Performance:

Automatic Campaigns:

• ACoS: 25-35% (often higher)
• Volume: High (broad reach)
• Efficiency: Lower (less control)
• Maintenance: Low

Manual Campaigns:

• ACoS: 20-30% (often lower)
• Volume: Moderate (precise targeting)
• Efficiency: Higher (more control)
• Maintenance: High

Why Manual Often Has Lower ACoS:

1. Precise targeting – Only relevant searches
2. Bid control – Optimize per keyword
3. Negative keywords – Exclude irrelevant
4. Match type control – Exact = better conversion

Why Automatic Can Be Valuable:

1. Keyword discovery – Finds opportunities
2. Low maintenance – Set and monitor
3. Broad reach – More visibility
4. Time savings – Less management

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Automatic Campaign Mistakes:

1. Set and Forget

• ❌ Create and never optimize
• ✅ Weekly search terms review

1. Ignoring Search Terms Report

• ❌ Not harvesting keywords
• ✅ Extract winners weekly

1. Too High Default Bid

• ❌ Max bid on everything
• ✅ Start conservative, adjust

1. No Negative Keywords

• ❌ Wasting money on irrelevant clicks
• ✅ Regular negative keyword updates

Manual Campaign Mistakes:

1. Starting with Manual Only

• ❌ Missing keyword opportunities
• ✅ Start Automatic, add Manual

1. Too Many Keywords

• ❌ 100+ keywords per campaign
• ✅ Focus on 20-30 high-value keywords

1. Same Bid for All Keywords

• ❌ No bid optimization
• ✅ Optimize per keyword

1. Ignoring Match Types

• ❌ Only using one match type
• ✅ Test all three, optimize

Which Should You Use? Decision Framework

Use Automatic If:

• ✅ New product with no keyword data
• ✅ Want keyword discovery
• ✅ Limited time for management
• ✅ Low competition niche
• ✅ Testing new products

Use Manual If:

• ✅ Have keyword data from Automatic
• ✅ Want precise control
• ✅ High competition keywords
• ✅ Scaling profitable terms
• ✅ Brand/competitor campaigns

Use Both If:

• ✅ Want maximum results (recommended)
• ✅ Have time for optimization
• ✅ Serious about PPC success
• ✅ Multiple products
• ✅ Scaling business

Conclusion: Use Both Strategically

The Automatic vs Manual debate misses the point: You should use both strategically. Automatic campaigns discover keywords, while Manual campaigns scale profitable ones.

Recommended Strategy:

1. Start with Automatic – Discover keywords
2. Harvest winners – Move to Manual
3. Scale Manual – Focus budget on profitable
4. Keep Automatic – Continuous discovery
5. Optimize both – Regular improvements

Remember: Automatic and Manual aren’t competitors—they’re teammates. Use Automatic for discovery, Manual for scaling, and both for maximum Amazon PPC success.

Need Help with Amazon PPC Campaign Strategy?

Our Amazon PPC management service creates and optimizes both Automatic and Manual campaigns. We’ll discover profitable keywords, scale winners, and manage your campaigns for maximum ROI.